California Penal Code section 152 states, “every person who, having knowledge of an accidental death, actively conceals or attempts to conceal that death, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.”
What Constitutes the Crime of Concealing an Accidental Death?
There are 2 basic requirements that form the crime of concealing an accidental death. They are:
- The defendant knew of an accidental death
- The defendant concealed or tried to conceal the accidental death
The first element of the crime makes it necessary that the accused person had knowledge of the accidental death. It also is the part that specifies that the death itself must be “accidental,” meaning that the actual occurrence that led to someone dying must have been unforeseen.
The second element requires that you concealed or tried to conceal the death. One can fulfill this criminal definition by doing any of the following:
- Concealing the body of the person who died
- Acting to impede authorities from finding the body
- Destroying the dead body or parts of it
- Concealing the tools used to kill the person or evidence
Concealing or destroying the body of the person who died would be a clear example of this offense, but there are several other ways to criminally conceal an accidental death in the eyes of the law. Hiding any piece of evidence or misleading authorities in any way would also be considered a violation of PC 152.
EX: 3 people decide to go surfing in an area where surfing is not permitted, due to the presence of large, jagged rocks. One of the surfers dies from smashing into a rock, and their body floats off into the ocean. The surfers panic, and decide to hide the rock that killed their friend. They later lie to authorities, stating that they were the only 2 people surfing together.
While they didn’t conceal the body, they both hid evidence of his death (the rock) and misled authorities, which are each violations of PC 152.
What are the punishments for violating PC 152?
Concealing an accidental death is a misdemeanor offense in California. It is punishable by:
- Up to 1 year in a county jail
- A fine between $1,000 and $10,000
How Can I Defend Myself if I Am Falsely Accused of Concealing an Accidental Death?
There are several ways to defend yourself if you are wrongfully charged with violating PC 152. They include:
- You didn’t actually try to conceal a death with your actions
- You didn’t know about the death
- You concealed the death under “duress”
There are circumstances in which one may hide evidence or lie to police without actually making an attempt to conceal any death. Doing this could result in being charged with another crime, such as PC 135 (destroying or concealing evidence). However, if you didn’t actually try to hide the fact that someone died, you couldn’t be charged.
EX: A person hosts a party where many of the guests are using illegal drugs. One of the guests who was using the drug tries to walk home but dies due to an overdose. The host of the party is not aware of the death, and before the night ends, the host wipes down all surfaces and gets rid of any evidence of drug use. The next morning, police come to his house, inform him a guest at his party has died, and then find drugs in his trash can outside.
In this instance, the host would not be guilty of violating PC 152. While he did destroy evidence by throwing out the illegal drugs, he did not do so because he wanted to conceal the guest’s death, he only did so to protect himself from drug charges.
Accidental deaths often create situations where people feel scared or threatened by others who know about the death. It may be the case that you want to tell authorities what happened, but others do not. If anyone who witnessed the death made a threat to you in order to keep you quiet, this is known as “duress,” and you would not be guilty of concealing an accidental death because you only did it because you feared for your own safety.